1. We are the elected Liberal Democrat Councillors for Carshalton Central Ward, which includes Carshalton Railway Station in the middle of the ward we represent. Carshalton station is essential to our residents as many of them commute to London, and others use this busy station to get from A to B in an area which does not have access to either the Underground or trams. The train is often the only option for our residents – we have just two lines one of which is Thameslink and the other a half hourly service to Victoria. We used to have a service to London Bridge but now there are only three morning rush hour services on this line.
Sutton has been undergoing a big population rise – one of the highest in London – and our ward has one of the biggest rises in the Borough as witnessed by the expansions to schools close to the station. We have one large F.E. college, two large girls’ secondary schools and five primary schools close to Carshalton Station which help contribute to railway journeys. These include Carshalton F.E. college and St Philomena’s Catholic school (over 1000 pupils) which both have a wide catchment area across South London including areas covered by Thameslink.
2. Our Ward is almost entirely residential and a significant number of our residents commute daily into central London for work. Many of these commuters use trains on the Thameslink Loop Line to travel to stations north of Blackfriars, including Farringdon and St. Pancras. One of our councillors used to use this route before retiring a few months ago and has a husband and son who still use this route every day to get to the Farringdon and St Pancras areas. Residents of the ward also tell us they consider they benefit greatly from having a direct service to St. Pancras International, for Continental Europe, and Luton airport.
3. For that reason we are concerned at the proposal, first set out in the London and South East Route Utilisation Strategy (July 2011), that all Sutton / Wimbledon Thameslink Loop Line trains will terminate at London Blackfriars from 2018.
4. Terminating Wimbledon Loop services at Blackfriars would result in our residents losing their cross-London service. This will penalise those of our residents who have made their residential, employment and educational location decisions on the basis of the existence of the cross-London Thameslink service. These residents, who chose to live in Carshalton on the basis of an existing pattern of transport connections, would lose a service that they have had for many years, and based their life around.
5. Any decision should take account of the impact of changes on the travel patterns of existing passengers, and of consequent requirements to change established travel patterns. It is because of the impact on our residents that we object to any proposal that would result in terminating Wimbledon loop trains at Blackfriars. If this service was terminated at Blackfriars, residents would ask for alternatives. The daily London Bridge service on this line was taken out some years ago because Thameslink was operating – now the changes would mean reduced service on the Thameslink service as well.
6. Not only would our residents lose a through service they have come to depend on, they would lose their connection with Eurostar and domestic long distance trains at St. Pancras International and Kings Cross. Instead they would have to change trains at Blackfriars, carrying possibly heavy luggage onto already crowded trains. This movement could be particularly difficult from the western bay platform when travelling north and to either bay platform when travelling south because of the platform lengths and the position of lifts and stairs at each end of the platforms. The recent Passenger Focus passenger survey found that having to change trains was a strong disincentive to train travel.
7. The London Borough of Sutton is a major business centre with many commuters and business travellers. It is therefore essential that all Sutton’s Thameslink stations retain their connections to central and north London and beyond, and maintain their direct link to St. Pancras and the City. As Sutton Borough is not on the Underground (unlike Wimbledon) nor Overground (unlike Croydon), nor is yet on the tram network (unlike Wimbledon or Croydon), it is even more essential that the Borough retains its existing rail networks. We are concerned that services on the Kent and SE London side are being improved at Sutton’s expense despite their having many more links into central London termini and beyond, and more choice of public transport travel than Sutton.
8. Many residents have contacted us with their concerns about these intended changes. One Hackbridge resident (who uses Hackbridge station, the next one to Carshalton on the Thameslink line) believes the remedy is to build another tunnel into Blackfriars and two extra rail lines going North past St Pancras. He also believes that whoever wins the franchise should run a fully Metropolitan service within the M25 so all London services are coordinated, and that services should be close to 24 hours like the tube starting earlier and finishing later. He also asks what old tunnels and bridges lying vacant in the Blackfriars and City (Holborn Viaduct) areas can be reactivated to allow more trains to pass through and Sutton services to continue North. These suggestions have some merit to help keep Thameslink services running from Carshalton to North of Blackfriars.
9. We thus strongly object to any proposal that would result in terminating Wimbledon loop trains at Blackfriars from 2018.
10. We are aware that Sutton Council is submitting comments, and support those comments. However, we are making this submission to draw particular attention to the impact on our residents in Carshalton Central Ward, and neighbouring wards where residents use Carshalton or Hackbridge stations.
JILL WHITEHEAD
HAMISH POLLOCK
ALAN SALTER
Liberal Democrat Councillors for Carshalton Central ward, London Borough of Sutton